Navigating the Complexity of Executive Hiring in FMCG
Debbie Morrison • May 28, 2024

Hiring executives is no simple task, in the FMCG & Food & Beverage Manufacturing sectors. The competition is fierce. Changes in consumer preferences and market conditions mean companies must innovate to meet the industry’s evolving demands.


Industry nuances add a greater layer of complexity to recruitment, highlighting the importance of leaders who can navigate challenges while also being forward-thinking enough to guide companies through uncertain times without losing consumer trust. Striking this balance makes strategic hiring crucial in these sectors.


So how can organisations prepare themselves to overcome these challenges and attract the talent? Just how vital is candidate evaluation in ensuring a good fit not only for the present but also for the future?


In this piece, we delve into strategies that employers and recruitment teams can adopt to better handle the intricacies of hiring executives.


Understanding the Current Landscape

The FMCG and Food & Beverage sectors exemplify dynamism and rapid change. These industries are highly responsive to shifts in consumer behaviour, technological advancements and global economic trends making them demanding environments for leadership roles.


While traditional leadership skills remain important they are now one aspect of what's required for success. 


The current business landscape demands adaptability, the ability to foresee changes and lead effectively – crucial for organisations to remain competitive. These skills enable companies to react promptly to market shifts, embrace technologies and navigate regulatory environments.


The Evolution of Recruitment Practices, in the FMCG and Food & Beverage Sectors


The FMCG and Food & Beverage industries are not rapidly changing but face unique challenges in executive recruitment due to several key factors;


1. Changing Market Dynamics: These sectors operate in paced settings where consumer preferences, technological advancements and economic conditions can fluctuate rapidly often leading to impacts.


2. Regulatory Compliance: Meeting local and international regulations related to food safety, environmental standards and labelling poses challenges that require expertise in risk management and compliance.


3. Supply Chain Complexity: With supply chains and logistics networks managing perishable goods and cold chain requirements while ensuring cost effectiveness, quality assurance and timely delivery presents ongoing challenges.


4. Technological Progress: The emergence of technologies, like intelligence, blockchain and the Internet of Things (IoT) offers exciting opportunities to enhance product quality and engage customers effectively.

However to effectively incorporate them one must possess an understanding of the technology's future applications, not just the technical aspect.


5. Sustainability and Ethics: The rising demands, from consumers and regulators for sustainable practices necessitate a delicate balance between economic objectives and social as well as environmental responsibilities. Implementing practices throughout a company's operations often involves investments and operational modifications.


6. Geographic Diversity: Managing operations across cultures and geographical locations requires executives to demonstrate interpersonal skills, including cross cultural communication abilities often in multiple languages. Adapting strategies to suit markets while understanding and respecting nuances can significantly enhance the pool of suitable talent.


These industries experience changes in consumer preferences, technological disruptions and evolving market conditions. Such dynamics call for an approach to recruitment and retention that emphasises skills beyond conventional metrics, such as strong visionary leadership capabilities aligned with the company's broader ethical and strategic objectives.


Furthermore, candidates' preferences have evolved well. Executives are increasingly seeking opportunities with organisations committed to sustainability, innovation and employee welfare. This shifting expectation, among candidates necessitates companies to reconsider how they portray themselves and engage with hires.



Shortcomings of Conventional Hiring Methods

Typical recruitment strategies often place an emphasis on candidates prior experiences and qualifications. While these aspects are undoubtedly crucial they may not fully capture a candidate's ability to tackle challenges or fit seamlessly into a company's culture in today's business landscape.


Challenges Faced by Businesses with Traditional Approaches


Rigid Skill Assessment: The traditional approach of evaluating skills often overlooks a candidates adaptability and potential for growth qualities that are vital in the evolving FMCG and Food & Beverage industries.


Excessive Focus on Experience: Although having a background and proven experience in the field is valuable an excessive focus on past roles can disregard candidates who bring fresh perspectives or diverse industry insights that could be advantageous.


Slow Adoption of Technological Progress: The delay in incorporating technologies into the recruitment process can impede the ability to attract and engage savvy candidates who are poised to spearhead digital transformations.


Current Dynamics in the Talent Market

The present talent market is undergoing changes well. Executive candidates have varying expectations and attitudes towards employers. The increasing popularity of work, the importance placed on achieving work life balance and the quest for fulfilling work are influencing how professionals perceive job prospects.


A recent report, from Elevatus points out that the market is expected to grow at a rate of 5.7% from 2022 to 2023 indicating opportunities that require a workforce equipped not only with technical skills but also a forward thinking approach.


Given the pace of growth and transformation, how are companies ensuring they can identify leaders who possess the ability to not just navigate but shape the future of the industry?


One approach is to focus on candidate assessments. Evaluating candidates has become increasingly vital in the recruitment process ensuring an alignment between a candidate's abilities and the long term goals of the hiring organisation.


The Role of Comprehensive Candidate Evaluation

Employers at this level are expanding their methods for hiring executives by incorporating holistic talent assessment strategies, sometimes even replacing traditional approaches. They have come to understand that thriving in paced industries requires more than matching technical skills or work experience. Evaluating candidates comprehensively plays a role in simplifying hiring decisions by focusing on a perspective that includes cultural alignment, leadership potential and the capacity for driving innovation and change.


Implementing a talent assessment framework that digs into various aspects of a candidate's profile is essential. This involves not examining their credentials but also assessing how well they align with the company’s values, their leadership approach and their ability to adapt to industry changes​ (JRG Partners LLC)​. These detailed assessments ensure that candidates possess not only the necessary skills but also the flexibility to grow alongside the company and industry.


Using candidate evaluation as a means for enhancement throughout the recruitment process helps employers gain an understanding of the qualities, traits and attributes most suitable for their organisation and critical leadership roles. This improves recruitment efficiency through customised strategies that can significantly streamline the hiring process.


By tailoring the search and selection process based on candidate assessments employers can ensure matches with candidates. This does not streamline the hiring process. Also enhances the chances of long term success for both the company and the hired executives. However while evaluating candidates is crucial many organisations tend to overlook the importance of nurturing an employer brand.


Harnessing Employer Branding

Can a robust employer brand act as a magnet for attracting talent in the industry?

In essence, yes. A strong employer brand isn't an asset; it's a necessity. In today's executive talent landscape professionals seek organisations that not offer competitive salaries and benefits but also stand out for their values, culture and innovative approach. Therefore enhancing your employer brand plays a role, in attracting talent and setting yourself apart from competitors.


Crafting an Appealing Employer Brand


Developing a compelling employer brand extends beyond marketing tactics enticing job postings and office perks. Here are some essential factors to consider;


Clearly Defining Your Mission and Values; Prospective candidates often gravitate towards organisations whose missions resonate with their values.

By expressing your dedication to sustainability, ethical standards and innovation you can significantly enhance your chances of attracting and engaging talent. This alignment not only attracts candidates but also fosters a deeper level of commitment and loyalty right from the beginning.


Highlighting the aspects of your company culture that embrace diversity, inclusion and employee well being can greatly boost your reputation as an employer of choice. Beyond offering work arrangements, create safe and open work environments that promote expression, creativity and innovation. Consider implementing wellness programs and continuous learning opportunities to appeal to executives seeking a thinking workplace.


Strategically leveraging media platforms can be instrumental in crafting a brand narrative. By sharing insider perspectives, employee testimonials and authentic CSR initiatives you can establish an attractive brand identity. This approach lays the foundation for connecting with candidates even before the initial interview takes place.


Engaging in thought leadership activities allows companies to position themselves as industry frontrunners, in the FMCG sector. Actively participating in industry dialogues publishing papers and hosting webinars are effective ways to showcase expertise and leadership within the field.

Enhancing visibility and portraying the company as thinking not attracts candidates who are excited to collaborate with innovators and industry frontrunners but also establishes a positive image.


Encouraging employee advocacy through testimonials can greatly boost the authenticity of your brand as an employer. Sharing stories of career growth, internal mobility and professional development, from employees serves as endorsements of your company’s culture and values enhancing its appeal.


A strong employer brand goes beyond attracting talent; it boosts awareness resulting in a pool of candidates who are already engaged with your organisation's culture and values. This pre-existing engagement streamlines the recruitment process increasing the conversion rate from candidate to employee. Additionally a solid employer brand reduces hiring expenses. Enhances retention rates by fostering employee commitment to the company's vision and ensuring alignment.


In a talent landscape a robust employer brand is not merely advantageous; it is indispensable. It sets a company apart, in a market. Draws visionary leaders who can drive organisational advancement forward.


When it comes to deciding between external recruitment, for specialised, to fill and key leadership positions the choice can have a significant impact on organisational continuity and innovation. While opting for recruitment has its benefits like an understanding of company culture and operations there are situations where external recruitment might be the more strategic option.


Advantages of Internal Recruitment

Handling the executive recruitment process internally is often preferred by employers and talent acquisition teams as it offers advantages;


In Depth Knowledge of Company Culture and Requirements: Internal talent acquisition teams possess an understanding of the company's culture, strategic objectives and specific needs. This knowledge allows them to pinpoint candidates who not only have the skills but also resonate with the company's values and goals. Such alignment is vital for long term success.


Cost Effectiveness: Managing the executive search internally can sometimes lead to cost savings compared to engaging agencies. However prolonged hiring processes or incorrect hiring decisions could result in cost implications.


Control Over Recruitment Procedures: Keeping the process in house provides companies with control over every aspect of recruitment from creating job descriptions to selecting candidates.


Developing Internal HR Capabilities: Handling the recruitment of top level executives in -house is a way to enhance the skills of the HR team by exposing them to recruitment methods. This hands-on experience is beneficial. Can lead to increased efficiency and effectiveness in hiring endeavours although it does come with its own set of risks.


When to Think About External Recruitment


While there are advantages to managing executive hiring there are situations where seeking talent outside the organisation may be an option;


Expanding the Talent Pool: By looking beyond traditional networks and local connections, organisations can tap into a diverse pool of executives and professionals who may not typically be reached through internal recruitment efforts.


Attracting Passive Talent: While job postings and branding efforts can attract job seekers – who represent a small portion of the talent market – the most exceptional candidates are often not actively seeking new opportunities. Engaging with this talent requires a nuanced approach that can uncover top tier professionals who might not have otherwise considered making a career move.


Conducting Comprehensive Skills and Personality Assessments: External recruitment agencies utilise assessments to evaluate candidates ensuring that those shortlisted not possess the necessary skills but also align with the values, traits and attributes essential for driving performance and enriching company culture.


Infusion of Fresh Perspectives: Introducing candidates can inject viewpoints, skills and creative concepts into the company essential for adapting and thriving in the rapidly evolving FMCG market. This becomes especially valuable when aiming to enter markets or revamp strategies. An external viewpoint is crucial in spotting talent.


Addressing Skills Shortages: When there's a lack of expertise or abilities within the existing workforce, turning to recruitment becomes necessary. This often occurs with advancements or when venturing into product areas where current employees may lack the necessary skills. Knowing where to locate talent and effectively presenting the opportunity to attract them is key.


Promoting Diversity: External recruitment serves as a method to enrich diversity within the organisation. Bringing in leaders from backgrounds can broaden the company's perspectives and approaches fostering an inclusive workplace environment.


Choosing between external recruitment strategies demands a consideration of the organisation's immediate requirements and long term objectives. While the potential cost savings associated with hiring may be appealing, external recruitment provides access to a talent pool infuses fresh vigour and introduces diverse talents beyond what traditional internal approaches can offer.

Every method has its advantages and potential drawbacks and the decision mainly relies on the situation and goals of the company.


Shaping the Future of Executive Recruitment, in FMCG and Food & Beverage


Successfully navigating the realm of recruitment requires a mix of strategic planning, flexibility and a profound comprehension of market dynamics and corporate culture. Throughout our conversation we've examined aspects of the recruitment process each underscoring the need for strategies in a landscape characterised by swift changes and intense competition.


Employers need to understand that traditional hiring methods, which often prioritise experiences and fixed qualifications, are increasingly inadequate in evaluating candidates' readiness to tackle challenges. The evolving nature of the FMCG and Food & Beverage sectors demands a hiring approach that values adaptability and thinking leadership as much as it values experience and expertise.


Comprehensive candidate assessment plays an important role, by enabling organisations to delve deeper into each candidate's potential. This method not evaluates their suitability but also their ability to progress alongside the company and propel it forward amidst an industry undergoing constant change. Nevertheless it's essential to acknowledge that recruitment is one part of the process; ongoing development is equally vital.

Building an employer brand and effectively managing both external recruitment resources are crucial, for attracting and retaining top talent.


As we look ahead the FMCG and Food & Beverage industries need to improve these approaches seeing the challenges of their markets as chances to innovate in recruitment. By creating environments that draw in flexible and tech savvy leaders companies can not just fill roles. Also enhance their organisational culture giving them a competitive advantage.


The journey towards recruitment is complex and ongoing. It requires organisations to be introspective, creative and inclusive. Industry leaders are urged to adjust their hiring strategies to align with the markets they operate in. By doing so, organisations expect to thrive in the dynamic and competitive landscapes of FMCG and Food & Beverage manufacturing. If you feel you would benefit from the expert insights gained from a professional candidate evaluation and assessment from trained professionals, enquire about our
https://www.elrexecutive.com.au/free-executive-talent-assessment-2.

A woman is holding two bottles of cosmetics in her hands.
By John Elliott April 21, 2025
Australia’s health, wellness, and supplements sector isn’t just growing. It’s exploding. From functional drinks to adaptogenic gummies, wellness brands have gone from niche to mainstream in record time. The industry is now worth over $5.6 billion, up from $4.7 billion in 2020 — a 19% growth in just three years. IBISWorld projects continued expansion with a CAGR of 5.3% through 2028. But behind the glossy packaging and influencer campaigns, something else is happening: the regulators have arrived. And most wellness brands? They’re underprepared. From Trend to Target The boom brought founders, fitness coaches, nutritionists, and marketing entrepreneurs into the supplement space. What many built was impressive. But what most forgot was how fast wellness moves from enthusiasm to enforcement. With more than 40 infringement notices and administrative sanctions in Q1 alone, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) strengthened enforcement of the Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code in early 2024. Prominent companies were named in public. Soon after, the ACCC revised its guidelines for influencer marketing disclosures and launched a campaign against the use of pseudoscientific terminology in product marketing. TGA head Professor Anthony Lawler noted in March 2024: “We’re seeing an unacceptably high level of non-compliance, particularly around unsubstantiated therapeutic claims.” In short: credibility is the new battleground. Why Sales-First Leadership is Failing Too many brands are still led by executives whose playbooks were built on community engagement, retail hustle, and Instagram fluency. That got them early traction. But it won’t keep them compliant — or protect them from an investor exodus when the lawsuits begin. The biggest risks now are not formulation errors. They’re: Claims breaches Compliance negligence Advertising missteps Unqualified health endorsements Reputational collapse through regulatory exposure And these aren’t theoretical. The TGA pulled 197 listed medicines from the market in 2023 alone — a 42% increase on the previous year — due to non-compliant claims or sponsor breaches. What the Next Wellness Leader Looks Like This is where many boards and founders face a difficult transition. The next generation of leadership in wellness isn’t defined by hustle. It’s defined by: Deep regulatory fluency Cross-functional commercial leadership (eComm, retail, pharma, FMCG) Reputation management under pressure Ability to scale with scrutiny, not just speed The leadership profiles now needed aren’t coming out of marketing agencies — they’re coming out of pharmaceuticals, healthtech, and functional food. They’ve sat on regulatory committees. They’ve built compliance-first commercial strategies. They understand how to win trust, not just impressions. Yes, this might feel like a shift away from the founder-led energy that made these brands exciting. But it’s not about slowing down. It’s about making sure you’re still standing when the music stops. Where the Gaps Are The underlying problem isn’t just non-compliance. It's immaturity in structural leadership. The majority of wellness brands haven't developed: An accountable governance structure; a scalable compliance architecture; a risk-aware marketing culture; and any significant succession planning beyond the founder. In fact, a 2023 survey by Complementary Medicines Australia found that only 22% of wellness businesses had dedicated compliance leadership at executive level, and just 14% had formal succession plans in place. This isn’t sustainable — not at scale, and certainly not under scrutiny. Final Thought The wellness boom isn’t over. But the rules have changed. Rapid growth is no longer enough. The brands that win from here will be those with: A compliance culture baked in Leadership teams built for complexity A board that sees regulation not as a barrier, but a brand advantage Those who don’t? They could be one audit away from crisis.
A Farmer walking through a barn, using a laptop with cows eating hay nearby.
By John Elliott April 17, 2025
Australia’s meat sector is facing a leadership vacuum. Explore the hidden crisis behind staffing, succession, and ESG risk in food manufacturing.